• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Jacobs Christmas

For the Love of Xmas

  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Search
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Search
  • Traditions and History
  • Around the World
  • Decorations
  • Recipes
  • Activities and Crafts
  • Movies and Music
  • Christmas Words
  • Gift Ideas
  • Traditions and History
  • Around the World
  • Decorations
  • Recipes
  • Activities and Crafts
  • Movies and Music
  • Christmas Words
  • Gift Ideas
The True Story Behind the Christmas Pickle Tradition

The True Story Behind the Christmas Pickle Tradition

You are here: Home / Christmas Traditions and History / The True Story Behind the Christmas Pickle Tradition

The Christmas pickle tradition is a hiding game: a green pickle-shaped ornament goes on the tree, and whoever finds it receives a small reward or a turn to open a present. Its exact origin is uncertain. The familiar claim that it is an old custom followed across Germany is not well established, but families can still enjoy the game without treating its legends as fact.

In a Nutshell

Christmas gift boxes on floor near fir Christmast tree.

Tradition has it that a pickle Christmas tree ornament is hidden on the Christmas tree. Come Christmas Day, the first person to find the pickle ornament hanging delicately on a branch of the Christmas tree gets rewarded. They might get to open the first present, or they get an extra present. But who started this tradition, where did it start, and when did it start? What do the Christmas ornaments look like?

Tradition Myths

Cloud of words related to myth and reality, fiction and facts.

If you have never heard of a Christmas pickle, you are in good company. Several stories compete to explain why an ornament shaped like a cucumber should hide among the lights and baubles. Many packages call it a German tradition, but it is unfamiliar to many people in Germany. The German connection may partly reflect the history of imported glass ornaments. That gives us a clue to the ornament’s journey, while leaving the origin of the hiding game open.

Another story has its roots in Germany. There was a soldier named Pvt. John C. Lower who fought for the Union side in the bloody American Civil War. This soldier was born in Bavaria, which is a region that is now part of Germany. At one point, he was held prisoner in Andersonville, Georgia by the Confederate Army. He was starving and fighting for his life. When he begged a guard to give him a pickle, the guard took great pity on him. In the family legend, that small kindness gives Lower the strength and hope to survive. The story continues that, when he returned to his family, he started a pickle tradition, whereby a pickle would be hidden in the Christmas tree for somebody to find. The finder would have success and good fortune for the year to come.

Yet another story, based on a medieval tale, is often told in Berrien Springs, Michigan. Berrien Springs has been recognized as the Capital of the world for the Christmas Pickle, with a pickle festival as part of its local celebrations. The revived festival is held around Independence Day, rather than in December. The tale has it that St. Nicholas saved two Spanish boys. They went to boarding school and were going home for the holidays. On their way home, they stayed at an inn, where the evil innkeeper killed them and placed them in a pickle barrel. St. Nicholas found the boys in the barrel when he stopped at the same inn, and he brought them back to life. But, legend has it that the barrel was full of meat for pies, and not pickles. Hmm.

A commercial explanation connects the story with imported Christmas ornaments. In the late 1800s, F.W. Woolworth Co. stores started selling glass ornaments in the United States, imported from Germany. Some of them came in the shapes of fruits and vegetables. When pickles were imported, it might have been assumed that pickle ornaments were part of a German tradition. It might very well be possible, however, that the company had an excess of pickle ornaments, and they made up stories to increase their sales. That explanation is plausible, but the idea that a retailer invented the game to sell excess stock remains speculation.

Origins of the Christmas Pickle Tradition

Work of Glass Blower, Glassblower Makes a Sphere.

The truth may never be known about the enchanting Christmas Pickle tradition. But, remember how glass Christmas ornaments were being hand-crafted and hand-produced in Germany, and then carefully imported across the ocean to the United States of America in the 1800s? Well, history books show that, as early as 1597, glass-blowing happened in a small town called Lauscha. Lauscha is located in a German state, which is called Thuringia. The town is known for their glass-blowing. Glass-blowers would produce glass containers and drinking glasses. In 1847, a few of the craftsmen from Lauscha began producing glass ornaments, called Glasschmuck. They were crafted in the shape of various commonplace fruits, and tree nuts.

The process to produce these unique glass ornaments involves hand blowing and molds. Soon after the ornaments were made, they were exported to all parts of Europe, England, and also the United States. 

Lauscha-made glass pickle ornaments connect the object with a real German manufacturing tradition. That is different from proving where the hiding game began. An ornament can be made in Germany, sold with a “German tradition” story, and become a family favorite elsewhere without establishing that the game was once common throughout Germany.

How popular is this tradition?

Green pickle character holding a gift on white background.

So how popular is the tradition? In a YouGov survey conducted in November 2016, 91% of German respondents said they did not know the Weihnachtsgurke custom. Only a small minority said they practiced it. That is a dated snapshot rather than a measure of today’s popularity, but it helps explain why the claim of a universal German tradition raises eyebrows.

Ornament sellers such as Old World Christmas have helped introduce the pickle to American families through their glass decorations and the stories accompanying them. The ornament itself is easy to understand once you see it: green glass disappears among green needles, making a surprisingly good hiding game. A tale printed on a package can become part of a family’s Christmas memories, even when it does not tell us who first invented the custom.

What do the pickle ornaments look like?

Dark green glass pickle ornament on a wooden background.

The pickle ornaments look like, well, pickles. They are made from shiny or matte green glass (rather than actual pickles). Some can be very detailed, others less so. Others might be personified with eyes and a mouth and dressed in hats and scarves. Still another ornament is a couple of pickle slices.

Where can one buy a pickle ornament?

You can buy traditional pickle Christmas ornaments online at various sites, including Amazon and other smaller shops. It might be interesting to take a moment and read the sites’ own story as to the origins and traditions of the infamous Christmas Pickle ornament!

How to Play Fairly

  • Choose a sturdy ornament and hide it where it can be seen without touching lights or fragile decorations.
  • Agree on the prize and whether everyone starts together.
  • Give younger children an easier turn or a separate clue.
  • Use a “look, do not grab” rule so the tree stays stable.
  • For several children, take turns hiding it or use a shared family reward.

Glass ornaments can break. A robust felt or other suitable version may be a better choice for a children’s game. Never put a real pickle or loose food into the branches as a substitute.

Explore Christmas in Germany or the history of the Christmas tree for more context.

Conclusion

So there you have it. While we do not have a definite answer as to the actual story behind the Christmas pickle, it might be more exciting to accept it as a mystery. Regardless, the tradition can still carry on: hang the pickle ornament up last, and hide it. Good fortune is part of the playful story rather than a promise. Choose a reward that suits your family and enjoy the search.

Related Posts

A traditional evergreen Advent wreath with four purple and rose pillar candles, unlit

What Do the Candles on an Advent Wreath Mean?

The Difference Between Christmas and Xmas

The Difference Between Christmas and Xmas

Christingle: What Is the Meaning and Story Behind This Christmas Tradition?

Christingle: What Is the Meaning and Story Behind This Christmas Tradition?

Christmas Bells - The Tradition and History of Bell Ringing

Christmas Bells: The Tradition and History of Bell Ringing

The Christmas Story for Kids (Birth of Jesus Christ)

The Christmas Story for Kids (Birth of Jesus Christ)

Who Were the Three Wise Men and Where Did They Come From?

Who Were the Three Wise Men and Where Did They Come From?

What Is the Real History of the Christmas Tree?

What Is the Real History of the Christmas Tree?

What Is a Yule Log and Why Do You Burn It?

What Is a Yule Log and Why Do You Burn It?

Why Is the Day After Christmas Called Boxing Day?

Why Is the Day After Christmas Called Boxing Day?

What Is Three Kings Day (Epiphany) and How Is It Celebrated?

What Is Three Kings Day (Epiphany) and How Is It Celebrated?

What Is the Difference Between Christmas and Hanukkah?

What Is the Difference Between Christmas and Hanukkah?

The Story of St. Nicholas, Santa Claus and Father Christmas

The Story of St. Nicholas, Santa Claus and Father Christmas

Previous Post: «What Is the Real History of the Christmas Tree? What Is the Real History of the Christmas Tree?
Next Post: Who Were the Three Wise Men and Where Did They Come From? Who Were the Three Wise Men and Where Did They Come From?»

Primary Sidebar

Christmas Traditions in Norway: How Xmas is Celebrated

Christmas Around the World

What Is the Difference Between Christmas and Hanukkah?

Christmas Traditions and History

52 Christmas Words That Start With B (List With Meanings)

Christmas Words

How Long Does a Real Christmas Tree Last?

Christmas Decorations

Christmas Bells: The Tradition and History of Bell Ringing

Christmas Traditions and History

Footer

About Jacobs Christmas

Photo of Jacob

Hi, I'm Jacob. This magical site was created for my love of Christmas. You can learn more about me or send me an email. Enjoy your stay!

❄ Christmas Countdown 2026

Have a Magical Christmas!

"Christmas waves a magic wand over this world, and behold, everything is softer and more beautiful."

Copyright © 2026 · Privacy Policy · Disclaimer